A Wisconsin brandy Old Fashioned combines brandy, muddled orange and cherry, sugar, aromatic bitters and a soda finish. Order it sweet for lemon-lime soda, sour for a tart mixer such as grapefruit soda, or press for a mix of lemon-lime soda and plain soda water. The recipe below makes one sweet version with 2 oz (60 ml) brandy and 2 oz (60 ml) lemon-lime soda.
This is stop one in 50 States, 50 Cocktails, our series exploring an iconic drink associated with each US state. Wisconsin starts the journey with a supper-club favorite whose ordering ritual is part of its appeal. These are editorial selections: a state's representative drink need not have been invented there or carry an official designation.
Jump to the recipe · Sweet, sour or press · Why Wisconsin?
Wisconsin brandy Old Fashioned recipe (sweet)
This is our measured house adaptation of the regional style, informed by Brian Bartels's recipe with Cocktail Chemistry and Anders Erickson's Wisconsin Old Fashioned. We specify granulated sugar, water and a fixed soda measure so you can repeat the same drink at home. It is not a claim to one universal supper-club formula.
Yield: 1 cocktail. Prep time: 5 minutes. Total time: 5 minutes. Glass: sturdy rocks glass, approximately 10–12 oz. Equipment: jigger, teaspoon, muddler, bar spoon and cocktail pick.
Ingredients
- 2 oz (60 ml) brandy
- 1 teaspoon granulated sugar
- 3 dashes Angostura aromatic bitters
- 1 teaspoon (5 ml) water
- 1 orange half wheel, plus 1 orange half wheel for garnish
- 1 maraschino cherry, plus 1 maraschino cherry for garnish
- 2 oz (60 ml) chilled lemon-lime soda
- Ice cubes, enough to fill a rocks glass
The ml measures are practical rounded equivalents of US fluid ounces. Use one measuring system throughout. The two orange pieces and two cherries have separate jobs: one of each is muddled and one of each is the garnish.
Instructions
1. Muddle the fruit and sugar
Put the sugar, bitters and water in a sturdy rocks glass. Add one orange half wheel and one cherry. Press gently with a muddler until the sugar is mostly dissolved and the fruit releases juice; avoid grinding the orange rind.
2. Add brandy and ice
Pour in the brandy. Fill the glass with ice cubes and stir to combine, lifting the fruit through the drink.
3. Finish with soda
Add the chilled lemon-lime soda and give the drink one gentle stir. Keep the muddled fruit in the glass.
4. Garnish and serve
Garnish with the remaining orange half wheel and cherry on a cocktail pick. Serve immediately, with the ice in the glass.
Sweet, sour or press: what changes?
The finishing mixer changes while the brandy-and-fruit base stays the same. Bartels's ordering guide describes the three familiar choices; individual bars can interpret them differently.
- Sweet: use the recipe above, with 2 oz (60 ml) lemon-lime soda. This gives a fruity, rounded finish.
- Sour: replace that soda with 2 oz (60 ml) grapefruit soda for this variation. Some bars use sour mix instead, so ask what they pour. A sour finish can still contain sugar; it does not mean unsweetened.
- Press: replace the soda with 1 oz (30 ml) lemon-lime soda and 1 oz (30 ml) plain soda water. This keeps the same total mixer volume while reducing the sweet soda component.
These are measured home variations, not three competing instructions for the main recipe. If you are ordering at a bar, say the spirit and finish together: “brandy Old Fashioned, sweet.” Naming only the cocktail leaves those choices open.
Why the brandy Old Fashioned represents Wisconsin
The association reaches beyond a clever substitution. Wisconsin's supper clubs have made this drink part of their hospitality, a connection recognized in the governor's 2025 Wisconsin Brandy Old Fashioned proclamation. That document specifically credits generations of family-owned supper clubs with developing the drink.
For this series, that living regional tradition is the reason to choose Wisconsin. There is no need to turn a complicated history into an unsupported single-inventor story. Nor does calling this an iconic Wisconsin drink mean every Wisconsin bartender uses the same spirit, fruit or mixer.
Wisconsin style versus a whiskey Old Fashioned
Our classic whiskey Old Fashioned recipe uses whiskey, sugar and bitters with an orange twist. This Wisconsin version changes three conspicuous things: brandy supplies the base, orange and cherry are muddled into the drink, and soda lengthens it.
Expect more fruit texture and a lighter, fizzy finish than in the short whiskey version. The muddled fruit stays in the glass; straining it out would change the serving style given here. Neither recipe needs to replace the other in your home bar.
Ingredient choices and common fixes
Which brandy should I use?
Use a grape brandy you enjoy mixed with citrus. Both bartender sources above specify Korbel, making it a useful reference point, but it is not mandatory for this house adaptation. Avoid accidentally buying a sweet fruit-flavored liqueur when you mean the base spirit.
The drink tastes too sweet
Try the press variation on your next glass before changing several ingredients at once. Keep the brandy, fruit, sugar and bitters constant, and substitute half the lemon-lime soda with plain soda water. That gives you a clear comparison. Cherry syrup adds more sweetness, so drain the cherries rather than pouring their jar liquid into the glass.
The orange tastes bitter
Use gentle pressure on the fruit flesh. Erickson specifically cautions against muddling the orange rind; pulverizing it is unnecessary to release juice. The aim is a drink with some fruit character, not finely shredded peel. Use a sturdy glass and avoid striking it with the muddler.
Sugar is sitting at the bottom
Spend a little more time dissolving it with the water and fruit juice before adding ice. Granulated sugar is specified here to avoid variation between sugar-cube sizes. If you switch to syrup, record its concentration and amount: a teaspoon of sugar and a teaspoon of syrup are not interchangeable measures of sweetness.
The soda tastes flat
Chill the mixer, open it near serving time and add it last. Stir gently after adding it. Do not shake the carbonated ingredients in a sealed cocktail shaker.
Frequently asked questions
Can I make a Wisconsin Old Fashioned with whiskey?
Yes, you can request whiskey as the base and still specify a sweet, sour or press finish. For this article's brandy recipe, keep brandy as written; a whiskey substitution changes the flavor and should be named when serving it.
Is a sour Wisconsin Old Fashioned a whiskey sour?
No. “Sour” here identifies the finishing mixer. It does not turn this muddled, built-in-the-glass drink into a separate shaken sour recipe.
Can I prepare it for guests?
Set out the measured brandy, washed and cut oranges, drained cherries and tools before starting. Build each drink in its own glass, then add ice and soda just before handing it over. Multiplying the liquid quantities is straightforward, but a jug of finished drinks will lose carbonation and continue diluting as it sits.
What should I try next?
Compare this drink with the whiskey Old Fashioned, or explore another regional classic with our New Orleans Sazerac. Both show how a few ingredient and serving choices can create a very different cocktail.



